How the battle for Poland's top judicial body has escalated and can Tusk take on a "Godzilla"?

, 20 October 2026, 15:00 - Anton Filippov

The conflict between Polish President Karol Nawrocki and the governing coalition led by Donald Tusk has reached an exceptionally high level of intensity.

The latest battleground for Poland’s leading politicians is the Constitutional Tribunal. More specifically, the dispute concerns who will control it.

The events of 14 October provided a striking illustration of the crisis, when attempts were made to prevent newly elected Constitutional Tribunal judge Maciej Berek from entering his workplace.

In addition to protesters, access for the new judge was blocked personally by the tribunal’s president, Bogdan Święczkowski. Polish President Karol Nawrocki later arrived at the scene, thereby expressing his support for the tribunal chief’s actions.

What triggered this acute political crisis? What arguments are the opposing sides putting forward, and what consequences could the dispute have for Poland? Read more in the article by Yurii Panchenko, a co-founder of European Pravda: Tusk vs. "Godzilla": Where will Poland’s battle over the Constitutional Court lead?

The roots of the crisis date back to 2015. At the time, Donald Tusk’s Civic Platform-led coalition, anticipating that it would soon lose power, decided to retain at least some control over the Constitutional Tribunal (CT).

The Sejm, Poland’s lower house of parliament, was due to appoint two CT judges to replace those whose terms had already expired. However, it ultimately elected five judges, also selecting replacements for three additional judges whose terms were due to end later that year.

After coming to power, the Law and Justice party (PiS) declared these appointments unlawful and selected five judges of its own.

The tribunal, however, eventually recognised the appointments of only two of the five judges. In other words, it refused to recognise the three "duplicate" appointees.

By then, however, the rival political camps could no longer be reconciled. Each regarded all five of its own nominees as legitimate judges and challenged the corresponding decisions of the Constitutional Tribunal itself.

Over time, Law and Justice managed to establish a majority among the CT’s judges, allowing the party to push through initiatives via the tribunal that might otherwise have faced opposition in parliament.

In 2024, commenting on the prolonged crisis in the country’s highest judicial body, Prime Minister Donald Tusk remarked that "the state has learned to live without the Constitutional Tribunal".

In 2025, however, an opportunity emerged to resolve the crisis. The terms of six judges expired, while those of two more judges were due to end towards the close of the year.

This gave Tusk’s coalition an opportunity to shift the balance of power within the tribunal in its favour. However, after six new judges were elected, President Nawrocki agreed to administer the oath of office to only two of them, refusing the others on procedural grounds. He also agreed to administer the oath to another judge who had been elected during the summer.

This still allowed the opposition Law and Justice party to retain a majority on the Constitutional Tribunal, with seven judges to three.

The remaining elected judges took their oaths before the Sejm, but the president and the head of the Constitutional Tribunal refused to recognise their appointments as legitimate.

Tusk’s coalition then turned to the Venice Commission for clarification. The commission emphasised that the president’s role in the appointment of judges was purely ceremonial and that the head of state should therefore not obstruct the administration of their oaths.

The Venice Commission’s conclusions gave the coalition an opportunity to go on the offensive.

On 14 October, another elected CT judge, Maciej Berek, took his oath before the Sejm. He is widely seen as a kind of battering ram, tasked with securing Bogdan Święczkowski’s removal as tribunal president and taking his place. Incidentally, Święczkowski has been nicknamed "Godzilla" because of his two-meter height, sturdy buildand tough temperament.

This is precisely why Berek’s attempt to assume his new duties on 14 October met with such resistance.

The political struggle over Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal has now become a zero-sum game, in which the winner stands to gain everything.

This article was produced within the framework of MOST – Media Organisations for Stronger Transnational Journalism, a Journalism Partnership funded by the Creative Europe programme that supports independent media specializing in international reporting