How Macron's leadership style led to his political decline and where France is headed

Thursday, 19 November 2026 —

For over a month, France has been consumed by an acute social and political crisis that President Emmanuel Macron can no longer stem.

Worse, the crisis comes when the country is less than six months away from a presidential election that looks likely to pit Marine Le Pen’s far-right against Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s far-left.

Read more about what happened to Macron’s once-promising centrist project and why he has become so isolated and politically powerless in the opinion piece by Zaki Laïdi, a former special adviser to the High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy of the European Union (2020-24): Macron’s failure: where France’s leader went wrong and why radicals could replace him.

The author begins by stressing that Macron’s political denouement is not unique. Every French president elected by universal suffrage since 1962 has ended his term rather badly.

"When Macron came to power, he wanted to transform the political landscape. He ended the regular alternation between the traditional left and right to govern from the center," Zaki Laïdi recalls.

He notes that it is often said that Macron single-handedly destroyed the two-party system that had dominated French political life since de Gaulle created the Fifth Republic in 1958. In fact, the right was already facing a serious threat from Le Pen’s party a decade before Macron’s presidency began, and the left was more fragmented than ever.

"What Macron does bear blame for is his failure to build something new on the party system’s ruins, which owes something to the deeper structure of French political power," argues the former special adviser to the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy.

He adds that Macron wanted to govern alone, with no intermediary between him and the people. Since he saw political parties as obstacles to be circumvented, he never tried to build a strong, properly structured political organisation around his ideas and policy programme.

"The key thing to understand about the French political system is that it is a republic that likes to have a king, only to tire of such figures and then try to behead them," the author emphasises.

In his view, Macron’s approach to management has proved catastrophic, and the end of his reign only accentuates this. Laïdi believes that Macron, in his vision of how power is to be exercised, is the heir of Napoleon and de Gaulle.

"The worrying scenario now is that his successor will be, too," warns the former EU foreign policy adviser's aide.

Le Pen and Mélenchon are also deeply attached to the idea that the sovereignty of "the people" should not be filtered through any intermediaries.

"France is a polarised society, like many others. But unlike others, its polarisation is dominated by two anti-liberal forces, the National Rally and La France Insoumise. This is a major political fact that could hasten Europe’s shift as a whole to post-liberalism," concludes the former adviser to the EU’s top diplomat.

If you notice an error, select the required text and press Ctrl + Enter to report it to the editors.
Advertisement: